Op-Ed on Trump Refugee Ban & Holocaust Remembrance Statement | Reconstructing Judaism

Op-Ed on Trump Refugee Ban & Holocaust Remembrance Statement

News
The following op-ed was originally published in Ha’aretz on January 30, 2017 at this URL: https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.768155
The article is shared with the kind permission of the author, Mathew S. Nosanchuk, a member of Reconstructionist congregation Adat Shalom and former liaison to the Jewish community under President Obama. 

Trump’s Refugee Ban Dishonors the Memory of the Jewish Holocaust Victims He Failed to Acknowledge 

As Obama’s liaison to U.S. Jews, I know the importance of statements commemorating the Holocaust. Trump’s omittance of Jewish Holocaust victims while inhumanely slamming the door on those fleeing persecution captures his historical ignorance.

Mathew S. Nosanchuk

And on the Seventh Day: U.S. President Donald Trump continued his dyspeptic blitzkrieg to impose his dystopian vision of America through the cruel bludgeon of his refugee ban and his ban on entry by Muslims from seven Middle Eastern and African nations. The Seventh Day of his presidential administration, that is. He has yet to rest.

In the cruelest of coincidences (if it was a coincidence at all), the president issued two statements Friday, one pulling the plug with a cruel immediacy on the admission refugees and banning those individuals – primarily Muslims – from coming to our shores because we only should admit people here who “deeply love America,” while the other commemorates International Holocaust Remembrance Day by sanitizing the memory of Nazi atrocities, making no mention whatsoever of the Shoah’s Jewish victims.

For me, these two acts are inextricably connected, a view informed by the three years I spent working in the White House as President Barack Obama’s liaison to the American Jewish community. As the Jewish liaison, I kept an eye on the American Jewish community’s collective calendar of annual milestones – mostly holidays, anniversaries and commemorations.

Every constituency with which we engaged expected the president to weigh in on their key events with a statement. For the most significant ones in the Jewish community, I would take the pen at first and turn the draft over to the incredibly talented bullpen of presidential speechwriters, who would then (in executive branch-ese) “chop” on them, making them soar and sound in President Obama’s voice.

Of vital importance to the Jewish community were those statements commemorating the Holocaust – the Nazis’ brutal mission to liquidate the Jews of Europe that resulted in the murder of six million Jews. The major annual Holocaust commemorations included International Holocaust Remembrance Day, established by the international community to take place each January 27 to remind the world of the murder of six million Jews. The day includes events designed to commemorate and educate the global community with the underlying message of “Never Forget” and “Never Again.”

In drafting statements on Holocaust remembrance, I always and deliberately included a specific reference to the fact that the Holocaust is above all else a tragedy that befell the Jewish people. It is an event that carries profound significance for all of humanity, irrespective of nationality, ethnicity or religion and had many other victims as well. But conscionable remembrance acknowledges the Jewish victims. It would have been tone deaf and negligent for me to write a statement in President Obama’s name that didn’t mention the fact that Jews – as well as political prisoners, Roma and homosexuals – were  victims of the Holocaust.

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau learned this the hard way when his 2016 International Holocaust Remembrance Day statement took the purely “internationalist” approach and made no reference to the Jewish victims. My White House colleagues and I knew that if a statement on Holocaust remembrance issued in President Obama’s name omitted mention of its Jewish victims, he (and I as the person charged with keeping an ear to the ground in the community) would have been pilloried, and the lapse would have been seized on by the president’s detractors to corroborate their wildly erroneous belief that he was insensitive to the Jewish community, unsupportive of Israel or, even that he was somehow anti-Semitic. (To his credit, Trudeau tweeted later the same day about the importance of fighting anti-Semitism and linking to his original statement.)

During his final year in office, President Obama accepted Israeli Ambassador Ron Dermer’s invitation to speak at a ceremony commemorating International Holocaust Remembrance Day that took place at the Israeli Embassy. Presidents do not typically travel to embassies to give speeches, and no president had ever delivered at an address at the Israeli Embassy. President Obama’s appearance there was historic. Ambassador Dermer knew that and so did we, which is why any policy differences that might have existed between the Obama Administration and the Israeli government, were inconsequential and irrelevant to the solemn act of coming together – b’yachad – for Holocaust remembrance.

The occasion, however, ended up being an even more powerful occasion that any of us imagined. In addition to commemorating International Holocaust Remembrance Day, the event also honored – posthumously – several American citizens who risked their own lives to save Jewish lives during the Holocaust, and after a rigorous vetting process to ascertain the veracity of their stories, received the honor of “Righteous Among the Nations” from Yad Vashem, Israel’s Holocaust Memorial.

One of the honorees was Army Master Sergeant Roddie Edmonds, who was captured by the Germans in 1944 along with more than 1,200 troops under his command. When the camp commandant ordered the captured American Jewish POWs to line up, Master Sergeant Edmonds ordered all his troops to stand together and told the commandant “We are all Jews.” Edmonds refused to back down, and the German officer, unable to identify the Jews, relented. Edmond’s act of courage saved lives of some 200 Jewish soldiers. Edmonds’ son Chris, a Baptist preacher from Tennessee, recounted his father’s unsung heroism, rooted in his Christianity, with warmth and power. Sitting a couple of rows behind the President during the ceremony, I could see that our Commander-in-Chief was deeply moved.

When it was his turn to deliver the keynote address, President Obama adlibbed, weaving Edmonds’ simple but profound declaration into his prepared remarks. Recognizing that the Holocaust was “a crime without parallel in human history” and that anti-Semitism and other forms of intolerance and hatred are on the rise in our times, he stated that “[a]n attack on any faith is an attack on all our faiths” and continued:

“For Americans, in particular, we should understand that it’s an attack on our diversity, on the very idea that people of different backgrounds can live together and thrive together.  Which is why –your father was right – we are all Jews… . When any Jew anywhere is targeted just for being Jewish, we all have to respond as Roddie Edmonds did – ‘We are all Jews.’”

When President Trump issues a statement that omits any mention of the Jewish victims of the Holocaust on International Holocaust Remembrance Day, a date – January 27 – that was chosen because it was the day on which Auschwitz, where evil and humanity conjoined to effectuate the mass murder of close to one million Jews, was liberated, he dishonored the memory of the Jewish victims of the Holocaust in favor of a boilerplate pledge to do everything in his power, “in the name of the perished … to make love and tolerance prevalent throughout the world.”

So should anyone be surprised when, on the very day when the world comes together to say “Never Again”, President Trump twice demonstrates his ignorance of history – first by issuing a thoughtless and self-aggrandizing statement on International Holocaust Remembrance Day that omits mentioning the Jewish victims and second, by signing his reckless, inhumane and un-American executive order slamming the door on men, women and children who are fleeing violence and persecution, and scapegoats millions of others by preventing them from traveling here because of their religion and nationality.

If “Never Again” and “Never Forget” mean anything, then let Americans of good conscience and character stand together and, with the same passion we saw in the streets of our nation’s capital and throughout America at the Women’s March, follow Sergeant Edmonds’s example:  “President Trump:  We are all Jews. We are all Muslims. We are all Refugees.”

From 2009-2017, Mathew S. Nosanchuk served in the Obama Administration in the White House Office of Public Engagement, on the National Security Council staff, and at the Departments of State, Justice and Homeland Security.

 

Related Resources

News and Blogs

Let's Journey Together

In an essay that appeared in Philadelphia’s Jewish Exponent, Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D., makes the case that Reconstructionist Judaism matters now more than ever.

News
News and Blogs

Let My People Stay: Jews Demand a Dream Act Now

Eighty-six Jewish activists, including six Reconstructionist rabbis, were arrested in Washington, D.C., on Jan. 17 in a bold act of civil disobedience in solidarity with more than 800,000 Dreamers.

News
News and Blogs

Striving Towards Racial Justice in our Jewish Communities

Reflections on the recent Jewish Social Justice roundtable meeting on racial justice and equity.

News

Strange Thoughts: A New Take on Loving the Stranger

To truly live justly, we need to move out of our comfort zones and embrace unfamiliar ideas and habits of mind. 

Article

Shofar Kavannah for Refugees

This ritual invokes the blast of the shofar to articulate the plight of refugees. It was created for use at High Holidays in response to the presidential travel ban.

Article

Desperate Immigrants: An Ancient Jewish Story

Abraham and Sarah’s desperate journey to Egypt as refugees reminds us that remembering the heart of the stranger is at the core of Jewish experience.

Article

Addressing Race as a Jewish Community

As a time to take responsibility for communal wrongs, Yom Kippur calls us to learn about and grapple with issues of race in America.

Sermon

I Want You to Know I Am Human: Listening to the Stranger Behind Bars

Freedom from bondage frames the Jewish story. How, then, can we fail to listen to those who are now behind bars? 

Article

Hagar: The Immigrant Worker

This provocative Rosh Hashanah sermon draws parallels between Hagar, Sarah’s mistreated servant, and today’s immigrant workers.

Sermon
News and Blogs

Light Through The Cracks

Rabbi Deborah Waxman reflects on finding spiritual equilibrium in a time of shifting sands.

News
News and Blogs

Just For A Time Like This

On January 29, 2017, Reconstructionist rabbis and thinkers gathered for a day of learning and study on “Moving Forward in Changing Times.” The gathering offered a range of Jewish approaches to finding spiritual strength as an activist, how to have difficult conversations with those with opposing viewpoints and how to stay sane and grounded in what feels like an avalanche of political change. 

News
News and Blogs

Politics From The Pulpit: Speaking Publicly About Repairing The World Together

Reconstructionist Judaism takes seriously our obligation to act together to address injustice and suffering. To do so, Rabbi Elliot Tepperman argues, our congregations need to be places where we can safely engage in political and ethical agitation and disagreement, while avoiding mere irritation.

News

From Tzedaka to Restorative Finance: A Curriculum

This Reconstructionist curriculum on wealth inequality was written for the movement’s Tikkun Olam commission in the winter of 5777 (2016-2017).

Document

Tikkun Olam, Unpacked

What is tikkun olam? In this extended article, Rabbi Jeremy Schwartz digs deep into the sources, underpinnings, and implications of “world repair.”

Article

For The Sake Of The World

Rabbi Toba Spitzer grapples wtih the traditional notion of Jewish chosenness, arguing that our Torah is integral to the maintenance and perfection of this world—even as we acknowledge that other people’s teachings, other people’s truths, are also a path to redemption. It matters that  Judaism survives—not just for our own sake, but because it’s good for the world, and because we have unique work to do.

Sermon