fbpx Reconstructing Judaism: Evolution in Action | Page 2 | Reconstructing Judaism

Reconstructing Judaism: Evolution in Action


Part of my “elevator speech” answer to the question “What is Reconstructionist Judaism?” has been the familiar, almost catchphrase: “Reconstructionists believe that Judaism is the evolving civilization of the Jewish people.” On a really short elevator ride, that could be the entire speech, leaving the person who asked the question slightly puzzled and really no better informed than they were when we left the lobby.

Recently, however, I have come to a much deeper appreciation of what an apt metaphor “evolving civilization” really is, and how it can help shape our response to the challenge of reconstructing Judaism for the 21st century. 

If you stand at our current point in the evolutionary process and look back over vast stretches of time, it is easy to see evolution as something resembling a New Yorker cartoon: in a straight line, a fish crawls out of the water; grows legs and lungs; starts to walk; walks on two legs; grows fur; picks up a giant club; sheds fur; puts on clothes; trades the club for a briefcase; and fills out an IRS Form 1040. A nice and orderly progression.

But, of course, that’s not what evolution actually is. If instead of looking back, you look at any one moment in the evolutionary process, it’s not a straight line at all. It’s really messy. At any one time, countless mutations and adaptations develop out of what already exists, and vie for survival in a challenging, even hostile, environment. Over time, the vast majority of those mutations and adaptations will die out, and only those best suited to the current environment will thrive. As the environment changes, characteristics that once assured a species’ survival can become vestigial or, even worse, can make survival even more difficult. A species that adapts successfully will survive — as long as it continues to adapt — and a species that does not make the right adaptations will become extinct.

Evolution is not nostalgic. Of course, there isn’t a new species in each generation. But what has come before is subjected to an unrelenting process of subtle and less subtle changes. The evolving species draws strength from the successful adaptations of the past, changes and grows through new adaptations, and will eventually shed vestiges of the past that may impede survival. 

Deeply rooted. Boldly relevant.

It is reasonable to look at the evolution of Jewish community in our time as a similarly messy process. In communities across North America, existing congregations and havurot engage in a constant process of change and adaptation in their effort to survive, to grow and to thrive in a changing world. How do we educate our children? How do we use new technologies to communicate and learn? How do we address environmental factors that result from those new technologies — from reduced attention spans to increased competition for our attention? How do we attract new members? How do we fund our community and its programs? How can we talk to one another about difficult questions — from domestic politics to Israel/Palestine — that might shatter us? How do we build a single community that can span the generations? How can we ensure that our communities model our inclusive values, so that Jews of color and intermarried families feel empowered and embraced? And through all of that, how do we preserve that which makes us unique?

Across North America, our affiliated communities are trying new ideas and new adaptations of existing strategies to meet those challenges and more.

And outside of our existing communities, new expressions of Jewish communal life that are not traditional synagogues are emerging from the lives of our children. Although some of those communities may not look like our existing congregations, they all emerge from our past and present, and are rooted in our culture and history. Those communities face many of the same questions as our existing communities — from how to fund themselves, to how to grow in a cohesive way, to how to succeed in helping their members live richly Jewish lives, often across differences — and constantly experiment and adapt to meet those challenges and to thrive.  

Over time, each of those adaptations, each new way of thinking about education and spirituality, or even marketing or finances will be tested by the environment. If enough successful adaptations emerge, take root and prosper, progressive Jewish communal life — and the Jewish people — will thrive in our generation and the next. If the adaptations that will enable us to flourish do not emerge and are not able to spread, our survival will be much more perilous.

Of course, no metaphor is perfect. And it is in the imperfection of the evolution metaphor that I see inspiration to act, and a guide to what Reconstructing Judaism can offer to Reconstructionist communities and the Jewish world. 

 In the natural world, the evolutionary process is random. Whether the right mutation will emerge in the right place and at the right time is entirely a matter of chance, so that countless random mutations over millions of years must appear and fail before that fish in The New Yorker cartoon can fill out a federal income-tax return. Whether a particular mutation that is successful in one environment will spread to other places where it might also thrive is also left to chance. Ocean currents, wind flows, bird migrations and other uncontrollable forces will determine where a new adaptation will spread, and whether or not it will be shared (or improved) in another environment.

The power of a movement — our movement — is that our adaptations and new ideas are not random, and we do not have to rely on happenstance to see them spread. 

Rather, really intelligent and thoughtful rabbis, professional educators and lay members in our affiliated communities across North America and beyond are purposefully building innovative and creative solutions to meet the opportunities and challenges of our changing environment. In Wyncote, our rabbinical students, our faculty, our Innovation and Impact team, and our Affiliate Support team bring fresh energy and new initiatives to the challenges of 21st-century progressive Judaism.

In addition, we do not need to rely on the vicissitudes of the shifting winds and tides for our best ideas to be shared and tested and improved by others. Rather, we can (and do), in a very intentional way, create connections among our communities and other fellow Reconstructionists across the movement so that Reconstructing Judaism can and will function as the laboratory and the proving ground for the best ideas in contemporary Jewish communal life.

How do we do that? 

Well, the most potent example is on the near horizon — our Reconstructionist convention in Philadelphia, which will be held from Nov. 15-18, 2018. Our convention will bring together hundreds of Reconstructionists from across the movement in one place to share our passion, our commitment and our best work. While the schedule is still in formation, we expect there to be more than 50 workshops in which lay leaders, rabbis and other professionals from across the movement will share the experiences of their communities, in addition to their best thinking about the opportunities and challenges that we all face. There will be time for “affinity groups” — rabbis, congregational lay leaders, educators, music leaders, executive directors and others — to meet, share common concerns and initiatives, and forge connections that they can build on long after the convention. Our plenary sessions will address some of the major issues of contemporary Jewish life. And there will be lots of opportunities to experience prayer, music and study as they are lived in other Reconstructionist communities across North America, and to bring those experiences home to invigorate our home communities.

Please come to convention, share what you have learned and be open to learning about the ways in which other communities are working to grow and thrive.

 Reconstructing Judaism’s commitment to nurturing good ideas and forging connections goes well beyond a convention: 

  • Every day, our Affiliate Support team works with rabbis and lay leaders from across the movement to help them develop and hone new approaches to emerging opportunities and challenges, and to make connections among congregations and havurot so that our communities can help one another.  
  • We sponsor President’s Forums, regional gatherings, the Reconstructionist Plenum and other opportunities for our community leaders to connect with one another, and share their problems and their best solutions. 
  • We work in close partnership with the Reconstructionist Rabbinical Association to make sure that rabbinic voices are heard across the movement. 
  • In partnership with the RRA, we have created the Joint Israel Commission and are forming a Tikkun Olam Commission that will bring rabbis and lay leaders from across the political spectrum and across North America together to create and share models of respectful discourse and effective engagement, drawing on the best work of our communities and the wider world.
  • We have developed the Reconstructionist Learning Networks to connect Reconstructionists from across North America in webinars and workshops that address “the questions of Jewish life that can’t be Googled.” 
  • Our camps — Camp Havaya and the new Havaya Arts — bring together children and teens from across North America for fun, and for potent learning experiences that forge relationships to last a lifetime.  
  • We sponsor Ritualwell.org as a forum for sharing and finding creative Jewish rituals and practices for a changing world. 
  • We provide innovation grants and mentoring to individuals and communities so that they can bring their best ideas to life.
  • This summer, we will continue our rollout of Evolve, an online discussion forum on the most compelling topics of contemporary Jewish life.
  • We use podcasts, webinars, list serves and other media to spread ideas and inspiration.

Why belong to a movement? Because the metaphor is flawed. Because it is only by joining with communities and fellow travelers from across North America, in a very intentional way, that the best ideas for building a vibrant Jewish communal life can be shared, tested, improved and put into practice. Together, we can both develop strategies to seize the opportunities and face the challenges of our home communities, and play a role in enabling the Jewish people to thrive.

Why the Reconstructionist movement? I believe that because of our commitment to the concept of peoplehood and to the imperative of cultural evolution; because of our commitment to the lay/rabbinic partnership, and to community-based and values-based decision-making; because of our commitment to participation and engagement; because of our openness to new ideas; and because of the empowered intelligence of our rabbis and lay members, we are uniquely suited to be, as we have always been, a powerful engine to drive the Jewish future forward.

It may turn out, I guess, that the world was created, exactly as we know it, in seven days by an all-knowing God. If that’s the case, I’m going to need another metaphor.

Chair, Reconstructing Judaism's Board of Governors

Related Resources

News and Blogs

Evolve: Sowing the Seeds of Constructive Evolution

Reconstructing Judaism has just rolled out Evolve: Groundbreaking Jewish Conversations with the intention of hosting difficult, groundbreaking conversations that are nevertheless mutually respectful and supportive. We invite you to visit Evolve and to join the conversations!


The Founding of the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College

A history of the beginnings of the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College

News and Blogs

Gathering Together

As we continue to develop new ways to build community across time and distance, we must also continue to find ways to “be there” for one another.

News and Blogs

Drawing Comfort from Community

Belonging connects us to something larger than our own individual experience. I belong to the Jewish people because claiming this connection enters me into a millennia-old conversation and joins me into community both vertical—all those who came before me and all those who follow—and horizontal—the Jews of today, in all our diversity.

News and Blogs

Reconstructionist Communities Make Disability Inclusion a Top Priority

With a welcoming ethos and a drive to break down barriers, Reconstructionist congregations and havurot have been part of a revolution that’s taken place in the public awareness of the importance of disability inclusion and related services.


Reclaiming Judaism After Centuries Underground

The small Italian village of Serrastretta has a hidden past: among its population are many families of anusim, hidden Jews whose ancestors were forced to convert to Catholicism during the Inquisition. Now, many locals are exploring their roots, thanks to new Reconstructionist affiliate Sinagoga Ner Tamid del Sud. 

News and Blogs

Why Belong?

Why belong to the Jewish people? Why belong to a synagogue? Why belong to the Reconstructionist movement? These are some of the most important questions that I am asked and that I, along with all of us at Reconstructing Judaism, strive to answer powerfully and convincingly.

News and Blogs

Does The Torah Require Us To Publicize Names Of Sexual Abusers?

What does Judaism teach us about how to respond to accusations of harassment or assault?

News and Blogs

Reconstructionist Movement Updates

Though we count time Jewishly, by any consideration the secular year 2018 is an exciting year for the Reconstructionist movement.

News and Blogs

Living the Mission: Values-Based Decision-Making and Reconstructing Judaism

The story of Temple Emmanuel’s ongoing exploration of Reconstructionist liturgy, and the rich conversations the process has opened up.

News and Blogs

Keeping Judaism Alive Behind Prison Walls

Serving Jewish prisoners in state prison, rabbinic students find new perspectives on freedom and responsibility.

News and Blogs

Let's Journey Together

In an essay that appeared in Philadelphia’s Jewish Exponent, Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D., makes the case that Reconstructionist Judaism matters now more than ever.


"Where Was God?" - Lesson Plan On Natural Disasters and Parashat Noah

During disasters and their aftermaths, many people wonder about God’s role in their suffering. This lesson seeks to explore God’s role in tragedy from a Jewish Reconstructionist perspective. This lesson is intended for children ages 8-12.


How Can Reconstructionists Pray?

How does a non-supernatural notion of God fit together with the practice of prayer? Rabbi Jacob Staub explores their intersection. 

News and Blogs

Nothing Neutral About It: Inspired by Reconstructionist Judaism in Switzerland

Paul Piwnicki, a Polish-born, German-raised scientist and Jew-by-choice, credits Reconstructionist thought with helping him develop a personal theology and practice. Piwnicki’s story highlights the influence of Reconstructionist ideas and thinkers, even in countries lacking Reconstructionist congregations.