Learn how the Momentum Campaign is reconstructing Judaism → 

Home » Events » “All of the People Israel are Responsible for One Another”: Reconstructionist Values That Shape Our Relationships with Israelis and Palestinians

“All of the People Israel are Responsible for One Another”: Reconstructionist Values That Shape Our Relationships with Israelis and Palestinians

Sunday, December 15, 2024 - 1:00 pm EST
 – Sunday, December 15, 2024 - 4:00 pm EST

Resources from Dec. 2024 Reconstructionist Israel Convening

Over 600 people from across our movement came together virtually on Dec. 15. 2024 to explore the shared values that shape our connection to Israel and our vision for a safe and vibrant future for Israelis and Palestinians.
 
Guided by the ancient Jewish principle of machloket l’shem shamayim, argument for the sake of heaven, Reconstructionists are committed to ethical, respectful discussion grounded in shared values, even about the most difficult issues. The plenary and breakout sessions modelled this approach while looking at what binds us in covenantal community in this painful moment. 
 
The entire convening was guided by a set of values around Israel and participation was shaped by behavioral norms. All participants agreed to the norms as a condition for attending. 
 
On this page, we are pleased to share recordings from the convening and other resources to spark further learning and conversation.  
 

Sign up for our Virtual Shabbat Box for more opportunities for learning and discussion every week.

Justin Rosen Smolen, Seth Rosen and Rabbi Deborah Waxman, Ph.D. reflect on the “All of the People Israel are Responsible for One Another” day of learning and offer suggestions for engaging with the materials on this page. 

Opening Plenary

Reconstructionists and Their Hopes for the Future of Israelis and Palestinians

Moderated by Rabbi Barbara Penzner, Interim CEO Reconstructionist Rabbinical Association, the panelists reflected on their personal journeys as Reconstructionists and their hopes for the future of Israelis and Palestinians.

Check out these additional videos we created from surveying our Reconstructionist Communities:

Speakers include:

This video includes a short video of reflections from a pre-event survey on the question “What does Israel mean to you?” and another short video of Jews of Color sharing a moment or experience that captures their relationship with Israel.
Captions are available by clicking the “cc” on the bottom right of the video.

Workshop Recordings

Watch recordings of our interactive workshops.

Thriving Communities, Complicated Times: leading through highs, lows, and everything in between

with Justin Rosen Smolen, Rabbi Rachel Weiss &  Rabbi Ruhi Sophia Motzkin Rubenstein

The Relationship Between the anti-Israel Upswell and Antisemitism​

with Rabbi David Teutsch

Progressive Israel Network – The Upcoming World Zionist Congress Elections and Why They Matter Urgently​

with Serena Oberstein & Nomi Colton-Max

Additional workshops

Not all workshops were recorded but we are listing them to show the scope of the discussions.

Expanding the Conversation on Israel-Palestine: Toward a New Reconstructionist Approach

with Sue Lanser, Joel Beinin, Marcy Boroff, Diana Ralph & Rabbi Laurie Zimmerman

RRA Members/RRC Graduates Serving on Campus​

with Rabbi Barbara Penzner, Rabbi Isabel de Koninck, Rabbi Jessica LottRabbi Danielle Stillman

‘Holding Each Other’ Creative Space with Ritualwell​

with Gabrielle Ariella Kaplan-Mayer

Closing Plenary

With Hope and Imagination: Reconstructionist Visions for the Future

Panelists grappled with questions related to their vision for the future, how Reconstructionist and Jewish values inform their vision, and how political identity labels (e.g., Zionist, anti-Zionist) are and are not useful to constructive conversations about Israel, Palestine, and the North American Jewish future.

Speakers will include:

Resources for Israel Convening

It’s not easy to talk about and process the first anniversary of Oct. 7, 2023, when war continues to widen, hostages remain in Gaza and a true ceasefire seems less and less likely. This episode aims to model such a conversation. In a wide-ranging interview featuring Rabbi Mira Wasserman, Ph.D., interim vice president of the Reconstructionist Rabbinical College and Elliott Glassenberg, senior educator at BINA: the Jewish Movement for Social Change, they and Bryan discuss Oct. 7 and how Israeli and American Jews have been impacted. They also explain the relationship between RRC and BINA and how it may be more important than ever for rabbis serving in the Diaspora to devote time to better understanding the dynamics of Israeli society. This is an excerpt from the episode.

Smartphone screen showing a podcast titled Evolve, featuring a conversation about Jewish social change.
You can find the full-length podcast episode here.

In preparation for Reconstructing Judaism’s December 15 movement-wide virtual convening, Rabbi Elliott Tepperman and Rabbi Rachel Weiss join Rabbi Deborah Waxman for a deeply thoughtful and nuanced conversation about the difficult and rewarding work of maintaining unity within Jewish communities that sometimes have diverse views on Israel and Palestine and the War in Gaza. Their reflections on how to cultivate spaces of growth, respect and accountability within the synagogue offer a blueprint for creating Jewish communities that are there for us during moments of joy and celebration as well as times of mourning and crisis.

Smartphone displaying the Hashivenu podcast on Jewish teachings, with flowers on both sides.

With the High Holiday season underway, Deborah welcomes Justin Rosen Smolen, Reconstructing Judaism’s Vice President for Thriving Communities and Partnerships, for a wide-ranging conversation about covenantal community. They explore how the idea of covenant, from biblical narratives to contemporary community-building, emphasizes relationships, mutual responsibility and interdependence. They consider how liberal religion can help address societal issues like loneliness and division, and advocate for conversations that build inclusive, thriving communities. Later, Deborah and Justin explore a Reconstructionist understanding of covenant, emphasizing the importance of shared values and intergenerational dialogue, and recognizing that while diverse perspectives may create tension, they also provide opportunities for growth and deeper understanding within the community.

Podcast app on a phone screen showing Hashivenu: Jewish Teachings on Resilience with two speakers images.
In this presentation, Rabbi Deborah Waxman explores a Reconstructionist approach to building covenantal community across difference.

Shutafut, meaning “partnership” in Hebrew, is a project of the Joint Israel Commission (JIC). Its mission is twofold: to inform and to connect

Shutafut seeks to inform Reconstructionists worldwide about remarkable organizations in Israel that may interest people in the movement. In addition, it seeks to identify ways that congregations, rabbis, and individuals across the movement can connect with these organizations if they wish.

Two hands of different skin tones engaged in a handshake against a neutral background.

Evolve: Groundbreaking Jewish Conversations is an online platform with conversation-sparking essays from thought-provoking rabbis, leaders and creators. Explore essays on key topics, as well as curricula, sermon sparks and videos that apply the best thinking to contemporary questions. Find essays on Israel and Palestine at the link below.

Logo with Evolve: Groundbreaking Jewish Conversations on a green and white geometric background.

Ritualwell is the most extensive online resource that curates original Jewish rituals for Jews and fellow seekers. We publish rituals, ceremonies, prayers and poems to mark sacred moments in Jewish life.  Find blessings, poetry and rituals that have been submitted to Ritualwell since Oct. 7, 2023 at the link below.

Ritualwell logo with text Tradition & Innovation on a light pink background.

There is a lot of debate in the Jewish world today regarding the question of when Israel-related speech crosses the line into antisemitism. These debates are likely to increase in the coming years, resurfacing as flashpoints on university campuses, in political campaigns, and in media platforms of all kinds.

Collage of documents on antisemitism and Israel-related speech with related titles and yellow background.

The Reconstructionist Network

Serving as central organization of the Reconstructionist movement

Training the next generation of groundbreaking rabbis

Modeling respectful conversations on pressing Jewish issues

Curating original, Jewish rituals, and convening Jewish creatives

The Reconstructionist Network